It seems this “thinking outside of the box” is pushed so much that it’s come to the point where the box itself has shrunk to nothing. Whenever we give our students some freedoms to think outside the box, too often they go to a land of complete distortion. For example, we made panna cotta the other day. This is a dessert so typically Italian: it’s dead simple, cream/milk + vanilla + sugar + gelatin; it’s cream and vanilla jello, for goodness sake. But if made properly, with good vanilla properly infused in the hot cream, with the right proportion of sugar and gelatin, it’s sublime. But the temptation to put your own twist on things is so great these days, it’s so encouraged, that the box becomes an experience far worse than Pandora’s. So when the students were given some free reign to do what they wanted to their panna cotta we saw things like black sesame seeds, juniper berries, cardamom, balsamic vinegar (which split the mixture), coffee, rose water, and so on. I was livid, made it known how I felt, and will remind them till the end of the term that you can break the rules of the game ONLY once you’ve mastered them. Unfortunately, I see this happening in the industry whenever these hot new young chefs take hold of a menu and do everything outside the box to the point of completely obscuring the classics. It’s come to the point that if I see something so simple as panna cotta on a menu I’ll order that first and only after I have a positive experience with the chef’s ability to make jello-ed cream will I pay for his/her ability to cook the fish.
This thinking outside the box for the sake of thinking outside the box has got to stop. Here’s a better metaphor for developing cooks: expand the boundaries of your box so you can fill it with mastered techniques and understanding of how food works. The box is not just a container of spices and herbs and whimsical combination possibilities. You are not mixologists (boy, some of those concoctions are in line with the juniper-balsamic-black sesame seed panna cotta – are there any bartenders left?): the box contains your tools, your hands, your techniques, and wise decisions. Ask any mature, master chef how they like their food and the answer usually has the word “simple” in it.
So before your hand reaches for the saffron, cardamom, or star anise ask make sure it first knows how to use the salt and pepper properly.
Tony Minichiello, Cook (and still maturing) Instructor